Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Is Richard Baxter’s Melancholia Still Relevant Today? Comparative Network Structures of Depressive Symptoms in Asian Individuals With Guilt-Rich and Guilt-Free Depression

  • Hong Seok Oh
  • , Junghyung Kim
  • , Jungsoo Park
  • , Kiwon Kim
  • , Eunkyung Kim
  • , Jaechang Lee
  • , Tae Young Choi
  • , Sung Won Jung
  • , Hyung Jun Yoon
  • , Hyun Soo Kim
  • , Eunsoo Moon
  • , Hyun Ju Yang
  • , Narae Jeong
  • , Heechan Yoon
  • , Tian Mei Si
  • , Roy Abraham Kallivayalil
  • , Andi J. Tanra
  • , Amir Hossein Jalali Nadoushan
  • , Kok Yoon Chee
  • , Afzal Javed
  • Kang Sim, Pornjira Pariwatcharakul, Takahiro A. Kato, Shih Ku Lin, Naotaka Shinfuku, Norman Sartorius, Seon Cheol Park
  • Konyang University Hospital
  • Yonsei University
  • Ajou University
  • Kangbuk Samsung Hospital
  • Hanyang University College of Medicine
  • Daegu Catholic University Hospital
  • Keimyung University
  • Chosun University
  • Dong-A University College of Medicine
  • Pusan National University School of Medicine
  • Jeju National University School of Medicine
  • Daegu University
  • Hanyang University Medical Center
  • Peking University Institute of Mental Health
  • Pushpagiri Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre
  • Hasanuddin University
  • School of Medicine (IUMS)
  • Kuala Lumpur Hospital
  • Pakistan Psychiatric Research Centre
  • Buangkok Green Medical Park
  • Hokkaido University Graduate School of Medicine
  • Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
  • Taipei City Hospital Taiwan
  • Seinan Gakuin University
  • Association for the Improvement of Mental Health Programs
  • Hanyang University Guri Hospital
  • Hanyang University

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Objective Historical theological frameworks, particularly those rooted in Christianity, have conceptualized guilt as a defining component of melancholy. This study compared the network structures of depressive symptoms in guilt-rich and guilt-free presentations of depression using a large-scale cross-national Asian dataset. Methods We analyzed data from the Research on Asian Psychotropic Prescription Patterns for Antidepressants, Phase 3 (REAP-AD3), which included patients with depressive disorders from 11 Asian countries. Network analysis was used to estimate symptom interactions and identify the central symptoms in each group. Participants were dichotomized according to the presence or absence of prominent guilt symptoms, as determined by the “feeling bad about yourself ” item of the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9). Results The network structures of the two groups differed substantially. In the guilt-rich group, depressed mood was the central node that was closely linked to self-blame. By contrast, the guilt-free group exhibited centralized networks with a loss of energy. Conclusion Variations in symptom network structures can be partly explained as broadly consonant with early ideas of Richard Baxter and Robert Burton on melancholia. Clinically, symptoms related to moral judgment and self-criticism may indicate potentially different specific therapeutic attention from individuals with significant guilt. Conversely, for those without pronounced guilt, interventions targeting physical and motivational symptoms such as fatigue might inform hypothesis-driven treatment strategies.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)861-872
Number of pages12
JournalPsychiatry Investigation
Volume23
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2026

Keywords

  • Christianity
  • Depressive disorders
  • Guilt
  • Moral judgement
  • Network structure
  • Patient Health Questionnaire-9

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Is Richard Baxter’s Melancholia Still Relevant Today? Comparative Network Structures of Depressive Symptoms in Asian Individuals With Guilt-Rich and Guilt-Free Depression'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this